We talk about the Algorithm when we talk about the big social media players - what is their algorithm? It’s a mystery, and it’s certainly set up to make you see what they want you to see.
What if Lemmy users had their own algorithms? Well, we already have a few - sort by Hot, Active, New, etc. Blocking users, communities, threads, keywords - that’s another algorithm - remove content that’s likely to be obnoxious. But we can do more than that when the algorithm’s working for us instead of a big company…
Could Lemmy have an AI algorithm that over time is trained to find stuff you like? Or trained to automatically catch and flag Nazi content or illegal content - would save the mods some work. Or trained to send you content you find lame when you’ve been doomscrolling too long.
Or for a simpler algorithm, give the users one of Tik Tok’s cheats - behind the scenes, Tik Tok staff would “heat” certain vids from certain creators, or with certain keywords, or that promote certain agendas… Like recording industry payola. What if you had the ability to sort by Hot, but with user-specified heat (or user-specified chill) - you like these posts, so dial up their karma, but you hate those posts, so dial posts with that keyword down, so they get pushed down in your feed.
Better than Meta algorithm Kremlinology, would you say? The one thing I want, though is open algorithms. We should know how they work, and what kinds of content they promote or block. Give the users the keys!
The best response to “the algorithm” is no algorithm. Sort by easily sortable metadata.
Sorting by date, or by karma formula (aka Hot) are algorithms. The key is that you chose those algorithms and know how they work.
This is the reddit “ackshually” game. Yes, any piece of code that accepts input and produces output could qualify as an “algorithm”, but no one, when talking about social media sorting algorithms means “sorted by date”. Let’s leave that shit on Reddit. I don’t want to play that.
I don’t know how Hot sorts. But if it’s more than just sorting by highest to lowest karma for posts, then I’d argue we should also do away with it.
We should rely solely on simple, transparent ordering
My apologies, I phrased that in a shitty way.
No worries. I read my response later and realized I sounded harsher than I meant to, so sorry for that.
All good!
Anyways, I don’t want to sound condescending, but thought you might be curious - seeing that Lemmy is open source, I found Lemmy’s Hot algorithm in the documentation. A bit more complicated than I thought it was, but the math’s pretty straightforward.
https://join-lemmy.org/docs/contributors/07-ranking-algo.html