Except that one is automatically versioned and would have saved you this pain, and the other relies on you actively remembering to reflexively commit, and then do extra work to clean up your history before sharing, and once you push, it’s harder to change history and make a clean version to share.
These days, there’s little excuse to not use COW with automated snapshots in addition to your normal, manual, VCS activities.
Who TF is eating a hot dog every day? That’s their idea of a minimum amount of a particular food?